Are Doctors Miracle Workers?
Interesting article on the New York Times this weekend by David Rieff on the topic of patient physician relationship. Here are a couple of thoughts. More to follow.
Trust Your Doctor?
The article by David Rieff , "Miracle Workers?" , highlights the erosion of the concept of "trust" towards one's physician. Paraphrasing George Simmel, inherent to the nature of trust is an element of faith. This faith is ‘conditional’, in the sense that it rests on the awareness that certain social and legal structures are in place to protect one's interests. One can trust because society is organized to prevent such trust from being abused. Nevertheless, trust entails a relationship between two parties that are on different levels of knowledge and power. When medicine was a humanistic science, doctors were regarded to be the exclusive keepers of their knowledge. This was essential to a patient’s trust.
The ‘exclusivity’ of a doctor’s knowledge no longer exists. Furthermore, modern clinical epistemology has moved the medical discourse from the realm of the "possible" (as I often say to my patients, the answer to any possibilistic question is always yes) to the realm of the “probable”, that is, the quantifiable world of statistics. This shift has been quite positive, allowing more sick people to be treated with more appropriate treatments. In this new paradigm, hope is rooted not in his faith but in knowledge that we are receiving the best treatment available against our disease.
Yet patients still have a longing for the days in which they could simply "trust" their doctor. This longing is partially fulfilled today by alternative medicine, whose language remains the language of the "possible" - the language of faith. Perhaps there is a fundamental human need involved, which the language of the probable and the ‘comfort of statistics’ can never fully assuage.
Contact Dr. Vidali
Click on any topic for articles!
ivf clomid diminished ovarian reserve amh day 3 fsh ivf explanation sperm clomifene habitual abortion infertility male infertility miscarriage "ivf success rates" Age and fertility alternative medicine fsh ivf failure pcos progesterone "fertility and the environment" Age Antimullerian Hormone IVF success rates Religion acupuncture amh levels autism embryo transfer ene femara fertility fertility test in vitro fertilization iui iui success rates ivf baby ivf birth defects nutrition polycystic ovaries stress and fertility "IVF cost" Clinic Statistics DHEA Ectopic Pregnancy Fertile period Tubal Disease basal body temperature birth defects blastocyst caffeine clomid success rates cystic fibrosis early menopause endometrial thickness environment failed ivf fertility risk factors fetal demise fetal heart rate fetal ultrasound genetics glucophage hMG icsi birth defects immunology insemination ivf success rate lifestyle and luteal phase metformin ohss ovulation induction philosopical issues in medicine pregnancy rates premature ovarian failure reproductive immunology serophene sperm donation sperm donor tdi